Skip to main content

Lahore: The Lahore High Court (LHC) has ruled that the University of Agriculture Faisalabad (UAF) falls within the jurisdiction of the Ombudsman Punjab. It dismissed the university’s petition, which argued that its statutory autonomy placed it outside the Ombudsman’s authority.

In a 14-page judgment, Justice Muhammad Ajmal Zahid held that the university is an “Agency” under Section 2(1) of the Punjab Office of the Ombudsman Act, 1997. It therefore falls within the expression “other institution established or controlled by the Provincial Government.”

The court examined UAF’s legal status, constitution, governance structure and administrative and financial arrangements under the University of Agriculture Faisalabad Act, 1973. It concluded that the autonomy granted by the university’s governing law does not, on its own, remove it from the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction. The court stressed that statutory autonomy does not necessarily mean freedom from government oversight.

The court found that the government exercises control over the university, pointing to several factors:

  • the Governor Punjab serves as the university’s Chancellor
  • the Chancellor has the authority to review the university’s decisions and order inquiries into its affairs
  • the government plays a role in setting the Chancellor’s eligibility and conditions
  • the university’s Syndicate includes members of the Provincial Assembly and provincial government secretaries
  • the university’s accounts are audited by a government-appointed auditor

The case began with a complaint a student filed through the Ombudsman Punjab’s Regional Office in Faisalabad. She alleged maladministration in the university’s admission process for the M.Sc. Chemistry programme for the 2017-18 session. The Ombudsman intervened and issued an order on her admission. The university challenged that intervention, arguing that it was neither established nor controlled by the provincial government. The High Court rejected this argument. The student has since completed her education.

The judgment has significant implications for administrative accountability in public-sector higher education institutions across Punjab.